Searchlight

Study · 2026-11-11 · 13 services · 24 questions · $45.67 spent

Leading software factories and agent-platform architectures

No one service found most: the top one found 20%, the top four together 59%.

Corrections

  • 2026-11-14: brave.research’s last place (0.0 useful findings per question, 95% range 0.0–0.0, $10.6446 spent) went unexplained. None of the 193 claims in its nine answers carried a source link, so none could be checked against a page. That is not finding nothing, nor a claim about other runs. We checked all nine stored answers and Brave’s documentation: no citation was dropped. Scores and spend are unchanged; nothing was rerun or regraded.

At the top

  1. Most useful findingsNo clear winner
    1. exa.research26.9
    2. exa.search26.2
    3. perplexity.research24.7
    Per question. The leader's range overlaps those of 10 others.
  2. Most found by no one elseNo clear winner
    1. firecrawl.search223
    2. parallel.search212
    3. tavily.search212
    Unique findings. The leader's range overlaps those of 5 others.
  3. Best valuebrave.search$0.0007per unique finding164 unique findings for $0.12 in all.

Before you compare

  • One run on one day, with 24 questions at most: treat small gaps as noise.
  • 6 services ran only 9 of the 24 questions, so compare per question.
  • Models extracted, checked and valued every claim; a service earns a finding only if its own cited page supports it.

Ranked by useful findings per question

The value of every finding a service earned on its own cited page, averaged over the questions it ran. The bar is its 95% range; where ranges overlap, the test cannot separate them.

search: hands back results search hands back results research: writes an answer research writes an answer

  1. 1research: writes an answerexa.research26.99 questions
  2. 2search: hands back resultsexa.search26.224 questions
  3. 3research: writes an answerperplexity.research24.79 questions
  4. 4research: writes an answerfirecrawl.research23.89 questions
  5. 5search: hands back resultsparallel.search22.924 questions
All 13 services
  1. 6research: writes an answerparallel.research22.09 questions
  2. 7search: hands back resultsfirecrawl.search20.524 questions
  3. 8search: hands back resultstavily.search19.824 questions
  4. 9search: hands back resultsbrave.search19.124 questions
  5. 10search: hands back resultsperplexity.search16.024 questions
  6. 11research: writes an answertavily.research10.79 questions
  7. 12search: hands back resultsclaude-native.agentimported4.724 questionsfreeform research brief mapped to questions afterwards; not posed each question verbatim; 49 WebSearch + 48 WebFetch calls; cost not metered
  8. 13research: writes an answerbrave.research0.09 questionsNo extracted claim carried a source link, so none could be checked against a page; this is not the same as finding nothing.
Full data every service, question and claim
Services

Every caveat, as recorded